Thursday, October 25, 2007

"Where's the beef?"

There's a mystery paleontologists have been puzzling over for decades that's pretty well summed up by everyone's favorite Wendy's ad.

Dimetrodon vertebrae found at HMNS site; additional object present for scale.

The Permian Red Beds in North Texas have turned up hundreds of Dimetrodons - the top predator of the era - but only a few fossils of the plant eaters they would have munched on. Without evidence of enough meat for this species to survive, how did they flourish for so long?



Dimetrodon ribs found by HMNS team.



In other words, Where's the beef?

About 50 years ago, E.C. Ulson, UCLA, hypothesized that Dimetrodons didn't eat plant eaters very often - because they were eating sharks.

Xenacanthus sharks of the era were unlike anything we've seen today. While the front of this prehistoric shark resembles modern species, it's back was shaped like an eel, and it had a long, poisonous spine coming out of its head. Most importantly, these were freshwater sharks that lived in the shallow, swamp-like habitat that was also populated by Dimetrodon 290 million years ago.

Evidence found by the HMNS paleo dig team supports this theory. For example, the team has found lots of Xenacathus teeth and poison spines at the site - but comparatively few examples of Xenacanthus coprolite (or shark poop). If the teeth were lost in the act of eating something, there would be coprolite around to prove it. Instead, the team has found lots of chewed-up shark skull.

An example of coprolite found at the site.

Something was eating the Xenacanthus at this site. Dimetrodon is the only species in the same weight class.

So, mystery solved?


31 comments:

Tarrignton Rivers and Matt Porter said...

Could the sharks have been canibals?

Houston Museum of Natural Science said...

Hi Tarrington and Matt,

Xenacanthus had tiny teeth and a small jaw - which were designed "more for snagging small fry," according to Dr. Bakker. They probably couldn't hae eaten anything as large as another Xenacanthus.

Good question - thanks for posting!

Erin

Anonymous said...

one day i went shopping outside,and in an ed hardy store,I found some kinds of ed hardy i love most they are Your website is really good Thank you for the information ed hardy ed hardy ed hardy clothing ed hardy clothing ed hardy shoes ed hardy shoes don ed hardy don ed hardy ed hardy clothes ed hardy clothes ed hardy bags ed hardy bags ed hardy swimwear ed hardy swimwear ed hardy jeans ed hardy jeans ed hardy mens ed hardy mens Thank you for the information

Levitra Online said...

I don't believe that this kind of creature be cannibal. He should eat little microorganisms or not.

buy generic levitra online said...

Great info.. Thanks

alan said...

I like to read this kind of data.


Smith Alan
http://www.raymeds.com

canadian pharmacy online viagra said...

hey buddy,this is one of the best posts that I�ve ever seen; you may include some more ideas in the same theme. I�m still waiting for some interesting thoughts from your side in your next post.

Edegra Online said...

Hi...
I keep thinking about it. Thanks for the information...

Howard said...

check this | there | this site | here | this page | there | check this

here | this site | this page | there | check this | this site | here

check this | there | this site | here | this page | there | check this

viagra generic said...

hey buddy,this is one of the best posts that I�ve ever seen; you may include some more ideas in the same theme. I�m still waiting for some interesting thoughts from your side in your next post.

philip said...

its really a nice one.Thanks for sharing.


forzest Online

Buy Generic Levitra said...

Very nice site and article. Amazing one, i appreciate this work.... This is a wonderful post Hey I see smart blog

Generic Levitra said...

Great Post and Nice Article.I like it.Thanks for sharing.

elliot thomas said...

Great article. First found difficult but interesting when read got some new information. thanks.

Virgin Girls said...

I am so sweet and pretty. I am working Bangalore Escorts agency in Bangalore city.

vip Bangalore escorts
Busty Bangalore escorts Girls
Bangalore escorts Girls
Bangalore escorts Models
Bangalore High Profile escorts

Virgin Girls said...

Bangalore escorts girls are really very beautiful and sizzling.

Independent Escorts in Bangalore
Collage Girls in Bangalore escorts
Russian Escorts in Bangalore
Bangalore Female escorts

Virgin Girls said...

Bangalore escorts provide independent Busty escorts service in Bangalore.

Bangalore escorts
Bangalore escorts service
Bangalore escorts agency
Independent Bangalore escorts
Bangalore independent escorts

Virgin Girls said...

I am the most attractive and talented amongst the superior escorts in Bangalore.

escorts in Bangalore
escorts service in Bangalore
Bangalore escort
Bangalore call girls
call girls in Bangalore

Virgin Girls said...

Top escorts agency in Bangalore and demanded escorts girl Payal Arora.

vip Bangalore escorts
Busty Bangalore escorts Girls
Bangalore escorts Girls
Bangalore escorts Models
Bangalore High Profile escorts

Riya Arora said...

Ektarao- Our Agency provides the High Class and the Elite independent Escorts in Chennai to the customer for enjoying the pleasure of our Escorts

escorts in Chennai

escorts service in Chennai

call girls in Chennai

Chennai call girls

Riya Arora said...



Chennai Escorts provide independent Busty escorts service in Chennai


Chennai independent escorts

collage girls in Chennai escorts

Chennai escorts models

Best Escort Service in Chennai

High Profile Escorts in Chennai

Riya Arora said...


chennaimodelescorts- provides you the most siziling hot models
Chennai escorts models
Best Escort Service in Chennai
Hot Escort Service in Chennai
VIP Escorts Service in Chennai

Riya Arora said...

chennaihotgirl- sensual chennai escorts avialable 24/7 for the customer
collage girls in Chennai escorts
Chennai escorts models
Best Escort Service in Chennai
Hot Escort Service in Chennai
VIP Escorts Service in Chennai

Riya Arora said...

vipchennaiescort-provide independent Busty escorts service in Chennai

collage girls in Chennai escorts
Chennai escorts models
Best Escort Service in Chennai
Hot Escort Service in Chennai
VIP Escorts Service in Chennai

Riya Arora said...

chennaiescortsqueen-provide independent Busty escorts service in Chennai
Chennai high profile escorts
Chennai independent escorts
russian escorts in Chennai
russian Chennai escort

Vicky Sharma said...

vip Hyderabad escorts
Busty Hyderabad escorts Girls
Hyderabad escorts Girls
Hyderabad escorts Models
Hyderabad High Profile escorts

Vicky Sharma said...

Independent Escorts in Hyderabad
Collage Girls in Hyderabad escorts
Russian Escorts in Hyderabad
Hyderabad Female escorts

Vicky Sharma said...

Hyderabad escorts
Hyderabad escorts service
Hyderabad escorts agency
Independent Hyderabad escorts
escorts in Hyderabad

Vicky Sharma said...

escorts service in Hyderabad
Hyderabad independent escorts
Hyderabad escort
Hyderabad call girls
call girls in Hyderabad

Vicky Sharma said...

vip Hyderabad escorts
Busty Hyderabad escorts Girls
Hyderabad escorts Girls
Hyderabad escorts Models
Hyderabad High Profile escorts

Vicky Sharma said...

Independent Escorts in Hyderabad
Collage Girls in Hyderabad escorts
Russian Escorts in Hyderabad
Hyderabad Female escorts